<<< o >>>when west meets east 26 comments + add yours
chromasia.com

I know I said that I'd put up all the shots from my China trip, but having trawled through them again I found two more: this one, and the one I'll put up tomorrow. As with yesterday's shot I guess this is also about contrast – though this one is about east meets west rather than rich meets poor.

As an aside: this was one of the first shots I took as I wandered around Dalian and captures, albeit accidentally, some of the anxiety I felt while taking photographs in a culture that I knew little or nothing about. See if you can spot what made me especially jumpy as I took this shot.

captured
camera
lens
focal length
aperture
shutter speed
shooting mode
exposure bias
metering mode
ISO
flash
image quality
RAW converter
cropped?
9.47pm on 24/10/05
Canon 20D
EF 17-40 f/4L USM
40mm (64mm equiv.)
f/5.6
1/30
aperture priority
+0.0
evaluative
100
no
RAW
C1 Pro
no
 
3x2 + travel [China] + people + urban
comment by Darrell at 09:00 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

The soilder getting off the chair by chance?

comment by justinh at 09:01 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

I'm really enjoying the shots from over there! What's the view on globalisation - is the style that's evident in this shot welcomed on the whole?

comment by bmoll at 09:02 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

A nice, extraordinary subject, judging by the rest of street elements. The colours of the posters are exposed, I like it, even if it's not your best :).

comment by ps at 09:03 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

good question. any problems?

comment by djn1 at 09:04 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

Darrrell: yep, for a scary second or two I thought he was about to wander in my direction and complain.

Justin: I'm not sure, I wasn't really there long enough to tell, but the impression I got from the few people I met is that the speed of change in China was simultaneously seen as a source of pride and something quite perplexing.

comment by Ed { tfk } at 09:54 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

I like the contrast, similar to yesterdays shot, between the posters and the clothesline.

comment by Fred at 10:45 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

Wow. This is getting better and better !! What a great idea to mix different tones and contrasts in this picture !! Color poping out of my screen from the 'west' and more subtle color for the 'east' ... The laundry hanging out the window, the guy in the back ... Everything fall very naturally into place. You were at your best on this one !! I wish I was there with you on that trip !

Fred @ 400iso.com

comment by PhilB at 11:26 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

Fascinating series so far Dave. Worth setting up a gallery for the China shots perhaps?

comment by Phil at 11:27 PM (GMT) on 6 November, 2005

I really like the bright colours in these last two shots. I think the soldier would make me a little nervous too.

comment by Rod Thomas at 12:43 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Contrast indeed... the colors of the photos versus the more drab colors of the street sceen... the seemingly care-free poses of the models versus the presumably not-so-care-free soldier apparantly guarding the corner. Nice job.

I too am guessing that your source of angst was just getting off his chair during this capture. Glad you didn't run into any issues there. And, are those bolts sticking up out of the sidewalk?

Can anyone out there interpret the writing (on the yellow tapestry and/or the red and white sign across the street) to add additional meaning to the scene for us? Thanx.

comment by Fellow Eskimo at 12:54 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

I prefered the monochrome shots...or the one from the plane. This just lacks an attraction to me...

comment by peter cohen at 01:17 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

What happens, I find myself wondering (perhaps because that's the way I think), to this photo if you make the soldier in color and everything else in B&W? I know... It's a very different picture, with a VERY different "point". Anyway-

comment by peter cohen at 01:19 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

BTW, I like the photo the way you've posted it.

comment by Joe Lencioni at 03:06 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

I find that this is definitely an interesting shot, but mostly because of the soldier. In fact, it was pretty much the first thing that I noticed in the photo.

Just curious, what was he doing sitting there? Was it common in the places you went to see soldiers around?

comment by Bernard at 04:27 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Just based on my year spent in Dalian, I don't believe that man was a soldier. Army regulars don't usually spend time on street corners...in fact, you'd be hard pressed to find a police officer when you needed one. A lot of the locals, mainly the older ones, seemed to enjoy wearing camouflage clothing which I believe harks from the days when one wore drab peasant clothing as a type of "uniform" for lack of better terms. More than likely, he was just very curious at the foreigner with the big camera.

comment by KK at 04:44 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

striking colours on this one. good thing the soldier didnt bother you.

comment by prasoon at 05:32 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

well, people have been speculating what made u go jumpy for this photo. I would say that it could very well be the 3 models pictured.. they are bautiful and they jus added beauty to ur shot. :)
nice capture btw..

comment by Geoff at 06:19 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Hmm. Interesting shot, but I'm more intrigued by your choice of title. Where exactly is the 'west' in this shot? The glamour photography? Isn't that a western bias to think that eastern cultures don't have glamour as a natural part of their culture and that it wasn't neccesaily imported from the West? I see that sort of photography to be a natural development in any culture, and China has certainly been developing rapidly in the last 50 years. So personally, I don't see anything 'west' in here at all, just a reflection on the modern 'east'. Nice shot though...

comment by Gustavs at 06:34 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Ah, such a great colors plus they are cute :)

comment by jxiong at 07:32 AM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

very thought provokin shot, makes us think of the effects of globalisation and reflects the way china is coping with it..

comment by Nilesh at 12:44 PM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Great shot. Goeff, it cannot be described as 'natural' development. Galmour is not imported from the west to east but western fashion sure is. It is the western infuence in fashion is what Dave is talking about.

comment by Lynn at 01:38 PM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Well, nice shot, but I prefer that witty one by the beach about fishing sign much more. Actually when you travel around China, you will see that kind of "west meet east" or dramatically contrasting scenes at almost every corner. It's quite exciting, inspiring and interesting to witness this great changing process! Thanks for showing this to all the world!!

comment by StuartR at 02:06 PM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Dave, I know exactly what you mean about taking photos in a strange culture... I was lucky enough to visit Hong Kong, Shanghai and Beijing this year, and felt exactly the same. In the event, HK and Shanghai were fine, but I got shouted at by a soldier in Tiananmen Square for taking his picture! I thought for a moment that I was going to get arrested, because the shouting attracted a lot of attention, but I did my best to look apologetic and walked away, and that was the end of it! I stuck to photographing buildings after that!

comment by djn1 at 09:10 PM (GMT) on 7 November, 2005

Thanks everyone.

PhilB: yes, I'll probably add another gallery to the site. Good idea.

Rod: yes, they are bolts, but I have no idea what they're for.

peter: good idea, but the soldier (or not - thanks Bernard, you may well be right) isn't in focus so I don't think that would work, at least not all that well.

Geoff: I may be wrong, but I suspect that the version of 'glamour' portrayed by these models is heavily influenced by Western practices and ideals.

comment by wild horse at 06:00 PM (GMT) on 15 November, 2005

wowww~~~~

rich and poor in the image, yes , this is china , developing china.

i from china, china go through changing, eastren and westren culture mixed, so , somebody rich and somebody poor.


i love photography, and taking. i wish communion with everybody:)

though my english is bad :(

comment by wild horse at 06:04 PM (GMT) on 15 November, 2005

by the way, the chinese word in photo mean is " if u want change, since your head " :)