<<< o >>>poverty has its price 62 comments + add yours
chromasia.com

I do have my own thoughts on this one, but I'd rather hear your's first: especially in terms of the story it tells.

captured
camera
lens
focal length
aperture
shutter speed
shooting mode
exposure bias
metering mode
ISO
flash
image quality
RAW converter
cropped?
9.53am on 26/4/06
Canon 20D
EF 70-200 f/4L USM
200mm (320mm equiv.)
f/5.6
1/200
aperture priority
-2/3
evaluative
100
no
RAW
C1 Pro
minor
 
3x2 + people + urban
comment by Fuzzy at 08:44 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Emotionally amazing...
I can't remember when was the last time when I was freaked out like this...

comment by Paul at 08:52 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

mmm....a story.....all I can think of is the phrase "she's a ten pinter!"

I like the low colour saturation, I'm glad she isn't my breakfast buddy.

comment by Mark at 08:57 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

The first thing I thought - given the positioning of the feet and the billowing skirt - was 'Ballet dancer'...strangely enough ;-)

I very much like the muted colour and toning you've given it Dave, as ever with your stuff the processing is bang on...kinda gives it an oldish/ridden down feel. Which still ties in with the ballet dancer thing if you ask me.

So do the plasters.

comment by Mark at 08:59 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

and I should learn to read titles really, then it really is about the plasters.

Mind you....I'm still sticking with the ballet scenario ;-)

comment by john at 09:02 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

It's a little bit Lewis Carroll to me... Alice after the mushroom.

comment by Dave at 09:09 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

What a depressing image! Never having seen the area the image was taken, all I can assume is that she is standing with her face against a cold stone wall. It makes me wince to think of the discomfort she must feel when walking. Sometimes an image is a novel in itself. This image however, is merely the first word on the first page of a very long book.

Great work!

comment by frisky? at 09:13 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

yea, sure does tell a story. love the "feel" of ths shot.

comment by doreen at 09:20 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

well, to me, she looks like a character from a fairy tale that's aged 50 years and also gained a lot of weight. sort of like a retired athelete. but there's still something sort of magical about this picture which i really like.

comment by Gonzalo at 09:25 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Simply beautiful. Great picture.
I like the color tone and the composition as well...
I'l be right back.

comment by NikitttA at 09:29 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

a bad woman is a sort of woman a man never gets tired of

*** stupendous ***

comment by Tomasz at 09:30 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Great shot. Strong emotions I feel, when looking at it. But I am not sure kind of emotions they are.

comment by djn1 at 09:38 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Mark: I removed the title. I'll add it back in later.

comment by Jaap at 09:40 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Brilliant! Absolutely! Love it, there's so much to see here...the tiny feet, the band aids, the rough skin, the wind apparently blowing some air up into that skirt (is it???)...
Very nice and certainly interesting!

comment by peter at 09:51 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Ouch! I'm glad they are not my feet. I love the tones you have created in this shot. Very good indeed

comment by Jamey at 09:59 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Lovely shot and it looks like you've done some ace dodging and burning too, unless the light was incredibly flat and you were just able to ramp the contrast across the board.

I know Paul described yesterday's shot as being Draganesque but this seems to fit that description much more so to my mind. I don't know how you feel about having your PP compared to his but rest assured I mean it as a compliment.

Very well done. One of my favourites. However did you get it so grey? It can't just be desaturation. It seems to have greyness built into it. It's just grey personified for me. Love it.

comment by Nick at 10:00 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

She's standing really close to that wall - either leaning against it hiding her face or holding herself in with her hands over the top of it, possibly even just looking over it at whatever lies beyond. I think the latter: she's forgotten the discomfort of those cheao shoes, the cold wind tugging at her skirt, oblivious of the photographer, and she's gazing, maybe out to sea?

I really like the effect the desaturated colurs have on this image.

comment by chiara at 10:19 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

This image is very interesting. I love the tone and the detailed textures you can see for all the types of surfaces there are from the skin to the dress to the cement.
The woman is a bit heavy but none the less her legs make for a great subject. It makes me wonder where she is and what she is actually doing. Is she waiting, is she resting… is she trying to avoid a puddle? It almost looks like she wants to fit on the tiny sidewalk at all costs.

comment by Giobird at 10:22 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Hey, great photo! I know what she is doing...she is looking over a bridge or something...?
Well done - as always.

comment by JD at 10:23 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

I'm curious about the title now (having got here after it was removed)

I got flashbacks to the sores I've had in this shot.

I figure that this this woman is probably sad...

urging to see over the wall, to see the greener grass,
Some sort of sad story about how:

er an't t'usband used to come ere evry year,
en now its just er,
every year,
in the same place,
staring over't wall

(I've intentionally put a strong yorkshire accent on her. ha!)

Brilliant post processing again :)
Your last 2 have been the best in while IMHO

comment by ROB at 10:26 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Whoa - its actually quite confronting, but maybe that is due it being an uncommon viewpoint.

Lookis like break time, to rest and look over a wall.

comment by M at 10:32 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Very nice. I like the way you matched the color of the bricks to her dress. The framing of this photo is very pleasing to the eye. Everything is balanced perfectly. There is more wall showing to the left of her than to the right, but her dress is blowing out more to the right than to the left. Very very nice. You snapped at just the right second.

comment by Fellow Eskimo at 10:37 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Um, is that a small person? Its an interesting shot, granted.

comment by Jennifer at 10:45 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Wonderfully done, but makes me feel a little sad! Maybe if we saw the top half of her, perhaps enjoying a view it, might evoke different feelings. The power of the camera - in the right hands of course! ;-)

comment by flying cow at 10:47 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

awww. the menfolk here are mean!

seems to me she just had a long hard day. her feet regularly suffer from shoe bites. she is waiting for her man and is watching as he is walking towards her, over the bridge with a bouqet in his hands.

c'mon. everyone deserves a little fairytale.

so, what was the title?

comment by RD at 10:53 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

Is she getting out of the way of a bicycle or motorcycle careening down the road? Maybe she's leaning into someone's window, engaged in neighborhood gossip. Or making a withdrawal at the ATM. Either way, her feet hurt! Great coloring.

comment by Dacian at 11:01 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

it looks like she is turning away from dust blown in the wind. either that or she just dodged a car that ran by her so fast that it lifted her skirt. at least that's the way i'm imagining the moment :)
i wonder why she is wearing those tiny (for her) and unconfortable shoes.
--
the colors and saturation are really beautiful.

comment by Carole at 11:29 PM (GMT) on 26 April, 2006

My first thought was, like Mark, Ballet Dancer, but close behind that thought, with the skirt just starting to billow, was an aging Marilyn.

comment by nuno f at 12:16 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

The first thing that I thought was a scene from the movie "Woman in Red". Everything is in place and I wounder what she is looking. I can only see the legs but I can imagine the person.

Excellent post processing.

comment by djn1 at 12:17 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

I've now reinstated the title.

comment by Rui at 12:34 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

great picture!

comment by Joseph Yarrow at 02:03 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Hmm, Very Marilyn Monroe...but then, not at all.
I like it, and yet again, perfect tones!!

comment by demetrice [handcanon] at 02:40 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

This reminds me of something Jan Saudek would do, though your work is a bit more SFW than his. Lately I've been seeing a trend of great tones across all the photoblogs I visit, and you are no exception.

comment by noushin at 03:10 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

For some reason the first thing that came to my mind was 'Ballet dancer'.
Very bold and beautiful : )

comment by jezblog.com at 03:13 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

This is very touching....... Its so human. It talks to us all. Still looking out to sea....... the hope of a better life on the horizon....... while actually being rooted in the reality of being trapped in poverty... over-weight.... and in shoes that hurt.
Its fascinating to see you tackle images with more meaning and narrative.....hey... nice one Dave.

comment by Jessyel Ty Gonzalez at 06:24 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Geez... Another winner, David. So much mood and mystery; I find it almost disturbing. Such great tones all around. Wondeful job.

comment by Armoks at 07:02 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

This is such an amazing pictorial representation of something so common yet something that is difficult to capture. you have captured so much about her life with so little actually in the picture. loneliness, depression, poverty, life gone by just to name a few...
Hats off to you Mr. Nightangle....

comment by Lito at 07:49 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

David, this one is simply great. Wow. Sad colors. Perfect structures. I'm impressed.

comment by susan b. at 08:54 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Wow. powerful.

comment by Sysagent at 08:54 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Mmmm sombre image or what...

I do like the processing you have done on this, it all seems to fit perfectly together and the subject material really is thought provoking.

"There's always someone out there worse off than you are..."

comment by bruno at 10:07 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

very nice contrast but i dont like the motif :( sorry again

comment by Marco at 10:14 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Old fashioned balance. Probably she was a dancer a long time ago. THe posture is almost perfect..

comment by Jem at 10:25 AM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Nominated you in the 2006 photobloggies my dear ;)

comment by Vivek Kushwaha at 12:31 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Oh! She is suffering form eliphantitis of simply obesity. Which ever she won't have fun knowin you are putting her feet's on display.
Looking the other way its art, the photography, it wants things for display. Looking critics and artise not humanity, at first place. Good Work.
:-)

comment by lee at 01:07 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

ok so the best photo I have seen on your site.

comment by David at 01:50 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Diabetes is brutal.

comment by Jason Lujan at 02:14 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

joel peter-witkin

comment by Philippe at 03:12 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Reality Check

Stunning photo...one of those that makes you unconfortable but you can't ignore the quality of the shot.

Great tones and details.

comment by Timothy Gray at 04:01 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

This is awesome! It's like a twisted illustration for Alice in Wonderland....lucky she didn't turn around!

comment by djn1 at 04:34 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Thanks everyone.

comment by PlasticTV at 05:26 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

There have doubtlessly been many beautiful pictures on your blog. But something from the photojournalistic approach is new. Nonetheless, your attention to detail is amazing. And with these details alone you unravel an entire story behind the picture. i agree with Armoks - hats off to you.

comment by micki at 05:42 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Truth is that I only feel positive when I see this. It stirs up memories of my grandma and her friends and how I would see them as a very small child. They all had thick legs and always wore dresses or skirts. Their feet were always sore, but there was a smile on every face and lots of love to give.

comment by Jason Wall at 07:06 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

She srikes me as someone out of a Flannery O'Conner novel or short story. The image is poignantly depressing. The way you desaturated, but kept the shadows deep makes for a feeling of cold and wet atmousphere, almost as though it has just rained or is threatening too.

You want to feel sorry for the woman, the way you feel some sympathy for anyone who doesn't seem comfortable with the everyday amenities of life. You are drawn to consider how much irritation she may deal with on a daily basis because her weight causes her shoes to fit poorly. I would image that might make it worse, because it isn't just a defect in the shoes, but a problem that may bother her in its own right. The irritation of the shoes may remind her of her weight, and that may lead to who knows how much guilt and self loathing. Though I expect it doesn't enter her conscious mind very often, except perhaps on dreary days when she stops to take in the weather, allowing herself a brief moment of repose on a moody afternoon.

I picture her in her mid 40's, possibly a mother, likely working in an office as a secretary of some sort. A jovial person most of the time, though a darker more cunical side peeps out when she thinks no one is looking.

Its a lovely photo Dave. Kudos.

comment by Adam Lee Dalziel at 08:03 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

Amzingly emotional picture - agree with jaso wall's comment above. Although i think that she just maybe cannot afford to buy new shoes - the picture is really emotive - and i think the rest of your commenters have said it all - great stuff as usual

comment by Sarah at 09:13 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

I'm not sure I want to know the story behind the image. I'd be disappointed if she was just withdrawing cash from an ATM. Poverty does indeed have it's price - in cheap shoes that pinch and rub.

That said, I do like this one. I always look but rarely comment, so please take this as a big compliment!

comment by mathew at 10:47 PM (GMT) on 27 April, 2006

This one really makes me feel uneasy for the sickly large person that is out of frame.. and with ever step she must take there is pain from this weight...

I really am bothered by that.

wonderful, wonderful shot.

really well done.

comment by Andrés Bortnik at 08:06 AM (GMT) on 29 April, 2006

This photo takes me out of time...would she ever know that her dress can look beuatiful?

comment by Mathieu at 11:08 AM (GMT) on 29 April, 2006

Great !

comment by andrea at 09:11 PM (GMT) on 29 April, 2006

Amazing image!
At first I thought it was a little girl, because of the dress and shoes, but then I had a closer look and it was almost heartbreaking. I love the tones, they make it kinda melancholic. Well done :)

comment by donosti at 10:48 PM (GMT) on 3 May, 2006

beautifull picture :D

comment by rambohoho at 09:17 PM (GMT) on 28 May, 2006

i love this shot. you have a great talent on observing people. thanks for sharing it, it makes us think.

comment by Ariela at 02:25 PM (GMT) on 14 June, 2006

I love this image, it draws you into a state of wonder. What does the rest of her look like? Is she happy? Where was she going? So many questions. Wonderful shot!

comment by bahat at 10:47 PM (GMT) on 3 June, 2008

Why the title cost of poverty I see obesity but the picture is captivating