<<< o >>>subtractive detail 31 comments + add yours
chromasia.com

This shot nearly didn't get posted because I just couldn't get the colour balance right. I really wanted to put the colour version of this shot up – the contrast between the warmth of the sand and the rich blueness of the sky should have been stunning – but it just didn't work. And I don't know why, it just didn't look right. So, and I guess I'm quite pleased about this really, here's a colorised version that I think is much better – more balanced, and quite a bit more dramatic.

capture date
camera
lens
aperture
shutter speed
shooting mode
exposure bias
metering mode
ISO
flash
image quality
RAW converter
cropped?
3.43pm on 5/2/05
Canon 20D
EF 100mm f/2.8 Macro USM
f/8.0
1/160
aperture priority
+0.0
evaluative
100
no
RAW
C1 Pro
no
 
3x2 + fylde coast [scenic]
comment by Kyle at 09:10 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

nice image. it looks very abstract but i like the color i think that it has a feel to it.
kyle

comment by owen at 09:25 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

fantastically abstract foreground - it took me ages to work out that it was just sand. Amazing clouds in the distance - did you get any shots where they are more prominent?

comment by Ted Morrow at 09:46 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

This is confusing - in a good way. I immediately thought it was picture taken from a fast moving car! Nice photo, as always.
Ted

comment by ellehm at 10:08 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

really really good picture!!

comment by Andy at 10:22 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

Very nice dramatic and abstract picture. This is more for my curiosity ... do you think you would mind putting up the color version of this picture even though you said that you could not get the "color balance" right. Anyway I just wanted to see what problem you were dealing with.

comment by Travis at 10:42 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

Dramatic you say? I'll do you one better, how bout frightening? The fact that there are no people in the image and the scale is really difficult to tell leaves me with a total sense of danger. Shadows can do many things for an image. You've utilized them here to really accentuate the unknown. I love that. I would be interested to see what this image looked like if you embraced this sense of foreboding and really brought down the brightness in the image. Specifically the upper rand hand corner. Damn fine beach photo!

comment by Fellow Eskimo at 11:08 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

Very nice photo, indeed. I do not think the sepia/color looks quite right. Especally not for the sky. But the foreground loks very intresting. I would love to see a color version of this.

comment by djn1 at 11:24 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

Thanks all.

As for the colour version: there isn't one, at least not one I can produce immediately (and I don't have time to do another one today). The problem, in this case, is that the image was converted to black and white with the channel mixer prior to me making two Curves adjustments to this image – one to the sky, and one to the foreground. What this now means is that the colours are totally off.

The original problem, which was a bit simpler, was what seemed to me to be a colour clash between the cyan of the sky and the almost rust-tinged sand. It may have been the case that people would have liked it that way, and if I get time towards the end of this week I may do another version, but for me it just didn't work.

Travis: because this scene is so familiar for me – it's our local beach, the shadows from the pier, a familiar horizon – I can't 'see' this as frightening. It's overly dramatised – in the sense that it's non-representational – but I don't find it foreboding.

I'd be interested to see what you make of tomorrow's shot.

comment by m at 11:33 PM (GMT) on 7 February, 2005

It is in the style of work by a famous photographer (or maybe not so famous ;-), however I can't recall who. Anyone esle know who I mean?

comment by jyoseph at 12:07 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

This is great!

At first glance it almost appears as though you are moving. The direction and pattern of the shadows give that impression. Beautiful photo!

comment by F. Castilho at 01:53 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

yeah, I was fooled too, I thought it was taken from a moving car

comment by billy at 06:13 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Honestly, I don't like the foreground. The shadows ans lack of color make it hard to *identify* what i'm looking at. however, the background--the mountains and clouds--are very dramatic

comment by David at 07:28 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

What is casting the shadows - a combination of trees and clouds? They serve the image well stacking up layers underneath the impending storm. The problem, or benefit, is that the eye is uncertain where to focus - on the foreground or background - because of the extraordinary depth of field the shadows create.

comment by Joe M. at 07:32 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Who cares if you can't tell what you're looking at? This is a good photo.

comment by djn1 at 09:13 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

David: the shadows are being cast by Blackpool's North Pier.

comment by ciro at 10:31 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Wow. Very nice.

comment by pierre at 11:00 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Nice photo
(again)

comment by Ky at 11:25 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

I found the picture a bit frightening too .. didn't realize it was a beach .. Very nice, catching picture!!

comment by chris at 11:35 AM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Like others I initially thought this was an image created by movement eg from a car; but as has been mentioned, the actuality is of no relevance - the image works because of solid composition / correct exposure etc. Great shot.

comment by RainKing at 03:18 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

I don't know about the color version, but this works very well in my book. I love the sepia-ish tones.

comment by miklos at 03:59 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Beautiful? I don't know.. It seems like it's all over the place.. It's too real to be abstract, but too abstract to be 'real'.. does that make sense? I guess that I'm all over the place too :) ..
Anyway, Dave, what are those spots everywhere in the picture? Like on the left side in the clouds (about 1/3 in from the left side of the photo), some on the right side by the horizon.. Some at the top of that shadowy area that looks like an O .. Some at the bottom right side of it..
Hot pixels? Can't really tell at first, if you just quickly glance over the photo, but once you notice them, you can't stop looking at them :) .. It makes the shot feel "dirty" ..

comment by djn1 at 04:44 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

miklos: the spots on the horizon are people (I think), the ones above the 'O' are stones/pebbles on the beach, and the ones in the clouds may be birds. I guess I could have spot-edited them out, but I don't find them particularly bothersome.

comment by VPra at 07:29 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

cool

comment by Adriana at 07:44 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

The good thing of beeing late for an entry is that you already answered all my cuestions (Lol). I realized imediatly that it was a beach but I didn't know what the shadows where from.

comment by john at 07:50 PM (GMT) on 8 February, 2005

Another example why you are # 1

comment by myla at 03:59 AM (GMT) on 9 February, 2005

This shot really sort of visualizes how I feel today -- wonderful shot.

comment by zerosun at 05:08 AM (GMT) on 9 February, 2005

wow. i'd love to see the color version, but with the subject matter here, its pretty stunning as is.

comment by Jesse at 06:20 AM (GMT) on 9 February, 2005

I found it difficult to connect to this image because I couldn't relate with the foreground. However, I looked the link of what cast the shadows, and that helped me appreciate the shadows. Oh, my limited mind :-).

comment by Dale Kewthrey at 02:28 PM (GMT) on 10 February, 2005

Too much Photoshop. Too little photography. Sorry.

comment by Yvette at 01:53 AM (GMT) on 14 February, 2005

I love the lines - great colorization choice too!

comment by Eric Hancock at 04:25 AM (GMT) on 16 February, 2005

Nice shot.